It is hard to reconcile the CJEU’s recent decisions on religious dress in the workplace with a genuine commitment to preventing discrimination, writes Paul Stanley QC

How far should the law guarantee individuals the right to wear clothes that demonstrate their religious belief? That question has, for some years, been controversial. Recently the European Court of Justice decided two cases, both concerning Muslim women who had been dismissed because they wanted to wear a headscarf. In one (Case C-188/15, Bougnaoui) the employee scored a narrow victory; in the other (Case C-157/15, Achbita) a defeat. How should one explain the difference between the results? And which tells us more about the court’s approach?

The basic framework of analysis is the same in both cases. Directive 2000/78 prohibits direct or indir...

Continue Reading for less than 70p per day!

This article is part of our subscription-based access. Please pick one of the options below to continue.

Already registered? Login to access premium content

Not registered? Subscribe

Login  Subscribe

On-line Web Offer

To save 40% off your first years subscription enter discount code: sjweb40 at the checkout